The Tavern-Style Pizza Pilgrimage
Discover why locals actually prefer 'square-cut' over deep dish.
Navi Walkability Score
While tourists clog the entryways of Magnificent Mile deep-dish parlors, locals know that tavern-style pizza—a cracker-thin crust cut into squares—is the true currency of Chicago pizza culture I Found Incredible Taver…
Chicago USA - GrazePath…. This route avoids the typical traps, starting at the Gino’s East South Loop location. While the brand is synonymous with heavy cornmeal deep-dish, the South Loop outpost excels at the thin-crust variety, providing a lighter entry point to a heavy evening
Gino's East | Deep Dish…
Gino's East Southloop De…. The logic here is simple: skip the graffiti-covered spectacle of the original location and focus on the spinach mozzarella sticks, which are arguably more essential than the pizza itself at this specific stop
Gino's East South Loop -….
The second leg moves south into Bronzeville and the near South Side, where Williams Inn Pizza & Sports Bar serves as the utilitarian heart of the crawl. This is not a venue for those seeking white-glove service or curated aesthetics. It is a sports bar where the tavern-style crust is sturdy enough to support a heavy hand of fennel-flecked sausage
Chicago USA - GrazePath…. The pro move here is ordering the wing flight; the skin is shattered-glass crispy and provides a necessary savory distraction while the pizza bake time stretches. It is a loud, unpretentious environment that captures the city’s neighborhood loyalty perfectly.
The journey concludes in Little Italy at Scafuri Bakery, a historic fixture that offers the necessary thermal reset. Moving from the salt and grease of a pizza crawl to the quiet, refined sweetness of an Italian bakery is the only way to end an evening in Chicago without feeling completely sidelined. The almond crescents and lemon knots are non-negotiable. They provide a sophisticated, low-key finale to a route that prioritizes regional authenticity over Instagram-baiting aesthetics.
What to Expect
Expect to walk approximately 4.8 miles if completing the full route on foot, though a short rideshare between the South Loop and Williams Inn is common to save time. Costs are moderate ($25–$40 per person including drinks). Gino’s East is generally efficient, but Williams Inn often has a wait for both tables and pizza, so timing this for a weeknight is preferred. Dress is strictly casual—this is a journey through sports bars and neighborhood bakeries. Scafuri Bakery closes earlier than most late-night spots, so check seasonal hours to ensure the almond crescents haven't sold out.
Route Overview
3 stops · 1.2 miThe Route
Gino’s East - South Loop
"Skip the deep dish wait and dive straight into their thin crust with a side of the spinach mozzarella sticks—it's the real hero of the South Loop location."
Williams Inn Pizza & Sports Bar
"Ignore the wait and the 'mid' service for the wing flight; it's a crispy masterpiece that pairs perfectly with their tavern-style thin crust."
Scafuri Bakery
"Skip the coffee and go straight for the almond crescents and lemon knots; it's a perfectly quiet spot to crash after your pizza crawl."
Insider Knowledge
At Gino’s East South Loop, ignore the deep-dish menu entirely; the tavern-style thin crust is consistently more consistent and less prone to 'soggy center' syndrome Gino's East South Loop -…. At Williams Inn, do not let the 'mid' service reviews deter you, but do order the wings immediately upon sitting down—the kitchen timing can be erratic. For Scafuri Bakery, the lemon knots are the sleeper hit, providing a sharp acidity that cuts through the lingering fats of the evening’s pizza. If visiting on a weekend, arrive at Gino's before 6:30 PM to avoid the suburban rush
Gino's East | Deep Dish….
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources & Further Reading
I Found Incredible Tavern Style Pizza In Chicago At Pizz' ...
facebook.com
Chicago USA - GrazePath | Authentic Travel Guides
grazepath.com
Pope Leo XIV's Guide to Chicago
choosechicago.com
The Best Places to Try Deep Dish and Tavern Style in One ...
we3travel.com
Gino's East South Loop - Chicago Restaurants
tripadvisor.com
Gino's East | Deep Dish Pizza on Instagram: "Creating ...
instagram.com
Gino's East Southloop Delivery Menu - Chicago
grubhub.com